Peer Review Process

PEER REVIEW PROCESS

General Rule: Mark incorrect sections on the right side of the line and use comments for specific guidance.

???? Manuscript Details

  • ✅ Title: Effective & Clear
  • ✅ Abstract: Complete essence
  • ✅ Intro: Up-to-date & Original
  • ✅ Method: Clear procedures
  • ✅ Results: Accurate analysis
  • ✅ Conclusion: Logical & Valid

???? References (80/20 Rule)

  • ✅ Min 80% from Journals (>2010)
  • ✅ Min 3 Book sources
  • ✅ 80% must be cited in text
  • ✅ High quality Figs/Tables

✍️ Writing Quality

  • ✅ Logical & Clear organization
  • ✅ Concise & Easy to understand
  • ✅ Proper Grammar & Spelling
  • ✅ Wise use of Abbreviations
  • ✅ Follows Journal Template

⚖️ Decision Categories

  • ???? Publish: No revision
  • ???? Minor: Editor can fix
  • ⚠️ Major: Author must fix
  • ❌ Rejected: Not scientific